Lib Dem Voice

The Saturday Debate: should the public be able to declare political affiliation on the electoral register?

Here’s your starter for ten in our Saturday slot where we throw up an idea or thought for debate:

In many states in the US people register themselves as “Democrat” or “Republican” (with also various options for “Independent” etc.) when they join the electoral register. These lists can then be used by the parties to hold primaries or caucuses to select candidates, letting only registered supporters of the party to take party. Open primaries* where anyone can vote are also held in some places, but if you only want your party’s supporters to vote in a primary then wrapping registering your support into the electoral registration system is a simple and cost-effective way of doing it.

So should a similar system be introduced in the UK?

Possible arguments in favour include:

  • It would be cheap and easy to add registering as a supporter of a particular party to the electoral registration system as we already have a list of officially registered political parties and are moving to individual registration. So it becomes a matter of recording one extra piece of information.
  • Lists of registered supporters could be used by parties to run primaries for any sort of election they wish, opening up candidate selection from often the small number of party members to the wider group of those willing to publicly state they are supporters of the party.
  • Lists of registered supporters would make it easier for parties to get out their vote and so raise turnout.
  • Lists of registered supporters would give parties lists of people they could approach for fundraising, potentially opening up party financial support to a large volume of small supporters rather than the current frequent reliance on small numbers of large donors.

Agree? Disagree? The comments thread awaits you…

* “Open primaries” in the US means letting registered supporters of other parties take part; in the UK it means letting non-members take part.

Andrew Hickey
Andrew Hickey

No, for various reasons: It's too easy for people to manipulate selections for smaller parties that way when they don't really support them. It could also easily harden people's voting preferences - "I put Labour on the register, so I'm Labour". The more information we ask of people, the more likely that some will not register *at all*. And people's political views should be able to be kept private. Imagine a household where one spouse is a Tory and the other supports Labour, but doesn't want their spouse to know...

Mark Pack
Mark Pack

Andrew: I don't quite follow the privacy point because you could register as independent (if mandatory) or not register political views (if not mandatory). Ie it's an issue that is important but very easy to deal with?


Comment moderation policy