Winston Churchill on electoral reform

18 March 2011 ,

Winston Churchill’s view on first past the post wasn’t exactly complimentary when he spoke in 1909:

Winston ChurchillThe present system has clearly broken down. The results produced are not fair to any party, nor to any section of the community. In many cases they do not secure majority representation, nor do they secure an intelligent representation of minorities. All they secure is fluke representation, freak representation, capricious representation.

Though do remember that by contemporary tabloid newspaper standards Churchill was an army-insulting, anti-Christian foreigner. And that’s without mentioning the drinking or depression…

Hat-tip: John Strafford via Left Foot Forward

Add your comment...
Please be polite, on topic and don't use multiple different names. Thanks!

3 comments
The Count
The Count

Winston Churchill on AV: "The plan that they have adopted is the worst of all possible plans. It is the stupidest, the least scientific and the most unreal that the Government have embodied in their Bill. The decision of 100 or more constituencies, perhaps 200, is to be determined by the most worthless votes given for the most worthless candidates. That is what the Home Secretary told us to-day was 'establishing democracy on a broader and surer basis.' Imagine making the representation of great constituencies dependent on the second preferences of the hindmost candidates. The hindmost candidate would become a personage of considerable importance, and the old phrase, 'Devil take the hindmost,' will acquire a new significance. "This method is surely the child of folly, and will become the parent of fraud. Neither the voters nor the candidates will be dealing with realities. An element of blind chance and accident will enter far more largely into our electoral decisions than even before, and respect for Parliament and Parliamentary processes will decline lower than it is at present."

Mark Pack
Mark Pack

Andy: I mention it as something that parts of the modern media hold against politicians and others in public life, not as something that should be held against them (hence also, for example, my reference to him being a 'foreigner' because of one of his parents).

Andy Mabbett
Andy Mabbett

Why is his depression mentioned as though it were a failing?

Trackbacks

  1. RT @markpack New from me: Winston Churchill on electoral reform – http://bit.ly/gtQaNf

  2. Neil Darby says:

    RT @markpack: New from me: Winston Churchill on electoral reform – http://bit.ly/gtQaNf

  3. RT @markpack: New from me: Winston Churchill on electoral reform – http://bit.ly/gtQaNf

  4. RT @markpack: New from me: Winston Churchill on electoral reform – http://bit.ly/gtQaNf

  5. Hamish Allan says:

    Churchill on FPTP: "Fluke representation, freak representation, capricious representation." http://is.gd/dlc6wL #yes2av #no2av

  6. Lord Matt says:

    Winston Churchill on electoral reform: http://t.co/sMdmyyh

  7. RT @markpack: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt

  8. Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt (via @markpack)

  9. "Present system has broken down. Results are not fair and secure fluke representation." Winston Churchill 1909 on FPTP. http://bit.ly/h7AlsM

  10. Ian says:

    RT @markpack: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt

  11. Dave Cross says:

    RT @markpack: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt

  12. RT @markpack: .@Jeremy_Hunt See you said Churchill very rarely wrong so do you agree with what he said about first past the post – http://bit.ly/h7AlsM ?

  13. RT @markpack: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt

  14. Mike Pitt says:

    RT @BelindaBG: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt (via @markpack)

  15. RT @markpack: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt

  16. Winston Churchill didn't back FFTP: http://goo.gl/nZ4PK

  17. no2av says:

    @MustBeRead @rcolvile Well Cameron said trust Churchill on electoral reform. Um, ok.. this is what he said about FPTP http://t.co/sMdmyyh

  18. @mathiasbarrett @YesInMay Yeah and have you seen what Winston Churchill said about FPTP? http://goo.gl/nZ4PK #yes2av

  19. @ChilternsBlue @ChrisWaldron76 I agree with Winston Churchill on FPTP – http://tiny.cc/12a05 #yes2av

  20. RT @markpack: Often overlooked: Churchill wasn't a fan of first past the post "fluke…freak…capricious" http://bit.ly/h7AlsM #bbcqt

C-