Liberal Democrat Newswire #57 is out: why the TV debates will be on the wrong dates

Edition #57 of Liberal Democrat Newswire came out last week, looking at why the TV debates will be on the wrong dates, who should you bet on to be next party leader and more.

You can also read it below, but if you’d like the convenience of getting it direct by email in future, just sign up here. It’s free!

Welcome to the 57th edition of Liberal Democrat Newswire which this time kicks off with the 10 key people for the Liberal Democrats in a hung Parliament who no-one is currently talking about, takes a look at possible next leaders and also includes news on the party’s most successful direct fundraising campaign.

As ever I hope you enjoy reading Liberal Democrat Newswire, and do let me know what you think.

Best wishes,


P.S. You don’t have to wait for the next edition of Liberal Democrat Newswire to keep up with news. My site is regularly updated with stories such as An odd detail about that Labour immigration leaflet.

In this edition:

9+1: 10 key Lib Dems in a hung Parliament

Houses of ParliamentBack in March last year Nick Clegg announced his negotiating team in the event of another hung Parliament. The creation of such a team was not a novelty, though making its membership public was an innovation.

One of its five members has now resigned. While Danny Alexander, Lynne Featherstone, David Laws and Steve Webb are all still in place, Sal Brinton stood down after being elected Party President. This was because she felt being in the negotiating team would be a conflict of interest with her role as Party President in overseeing consultation with party members on the outcome of any such negotiation.

Despite the smallness of the team and the proximity of the election, not to mention the need for a modicum of sensible preparation by any team member, no replacement has yet been announced and nor are there noises about it being any day now.

(The rules for the negotiating team, by the way, require “due regard to diversity”, which would be hard to square with not replacing Sal Brinton.)

However, there are also another nine vacancies in key posts elsewhere related to any hung Parliament.

Earlier in the Parliament the party reformed its ‘triple lock’ process (which confusingly involved four steps) following the experience of 2010. One of the changes was to create a reference group of nine to be a sounding board during hung Parliament negotiations:

There shall be a reference group consisting of not more than nine people (none of whom shall be members of the negotiating team) appointed equally by (i) the Federal Policy Committee (ii) the Federal Executive and (iii) the Westminster Parliamentary Parties [i.e. MPs and peers] … The negotiating team shall report regularly to the Leader and the reference group, and shall have regard to their respective views.

Nine key people, none of whom have yet been selected but who will play a key role when they are. Which makes the considerable quiet over any of the selections rather out of kilter with their potential importance.

For the full revised triple lock process see the update to my article on its history.

Election TV debates: the dates will be all wrong

TV debate 2010Debate has raged over who should debate in the TV debates, but the timing of them has (once again) been almost totally neglected, which also means that (once again) the dates of them will be wrong.

It isn’t just the TV debates that have a problem. Pretty much the whole of the media’s coverage of elections, not to mention civic society’s engagement with the elections and more, is geared around the idea that people voting on polling day itself.

In increasing numbers they don’t. Seven million postal votes were issued in 2010 and the number is looking set to be even high this time round.

Not only are postal voters increasingly numerous, they also vote increasingly early as those administering elections have grown more and more keen to send out postal votes as promptly as possible given the administrative burdens involved in processing returned ballots (especially since the welcome introduction of the need to check security information on all returned postal ballots rather than on just a sample).

This time round, soundings with electoral returning officers show that most are going to start sending out postal ballots in the week commencing 13 April, weeks before polling day itself.

Rather like the frog that does not notice the slowly increasing temperature of the pot it is being cooked in, the long-term, sustained and major increase in postal voting levels has crept up and up and up without any one seismic change – and hence the numbers of people voting well before polling day has still not really been grasped by many who still set the timetables for their activity as if people only vote on polling day.

Grassroots electoral campaigners have long since learnt to run two ‘polling day’ operations but much of the rest of how elections, their coverage and the lobbying of candidates is organised is based on an increasingly antiquated notion of when people vote, with debates, events and coverage galore therefore happening after millions have voted.

Money and volunteers flow into Liberal Democrat HQ

Lib Dem HQ receptionOver £50,000 was raised in just one Saturday – 31st January – by the party’s fundraising operation as the finale of a ‘double your donation’ drive in January.

A group of donors were recruited before Christmas who promised to double the value of donations received during January and the final rush to the deadline capped a fundraising drive which brought in £300,000: a very large sum by the party’s standards (though somewhat modest by the standards of the mammoth donations Labour and the Tories pick up from select individuals).

This was the party’s most successful direct fundraising operation ever, beating even that run for the Eastleigh by-election.

It isn’t only money that has been flowing in. So too have volunteers, especially for the Tuesday night volunteer sessions (a regular participant at which is a certain Mr. Clegg, whose diary has been cleared of several other Tuesday engagements as he enjoyed taking part so much). As a result, the pressure on space is now so great that the party is having to look at taking on extra office space to cope with the influx of help.

Importantly for the party’s long run health, membership is also continuing to grow – up for the 6th quarter in a row when the figures came out for the end of 2014. Moreover, 78% of party members are now on direct debit or recurring credit/debit card payments. This high proportion of automatic renewals marks major progress in improving the party’s membership systems and means that efforts can be concentrated on serious waverers and recruiting new members, rather than having to be eaten up sorting out payments from people who want to renew but just haven’t quite done so yet.

To find out more about what’s happening at party HQ, watch this tour round the place with Paddy Ashdown:

Key party posts filled in new elections

Neil Fawcett, FE Deputy ChairI nearly wrote “New people elected…” but it was hardly a tsunami of new faces in the recent elections by the Federal Executive to fill a set of party posts. Incumbents and highly familiar white, male faces were more the order of the day.

That said, there are no incumbents back who I would have sacked if handed dictatorial powers for the day, and new FE Deputy Chair Neil Fawcett is very good on how the party needs to strengthen its grassroots organisation. It is, however, also a reminder of how the party’s drive to improve its diversity needs to work on both public office and party office.

Those elected were:

  • Federal Executive (FE) Deputy Chair: Neil Fawcett
  • Federal Finance and Administration Committee Chair: Peter Dunphy
  • Party Treasurer: Ian Wrigglesworth
  • Campaigns and Communications Committee Chair: James Gurling
  • International Relations Committee Chair: Robert Woodthorpe-Browne

Don’t miss out on new Lib Dem stories

Lib Dem logoAs well as this monthly email newsletter, I also offer a couple of daily emails:

  • a daily round up of the new stories posted up on the official Liberal Democrat website, and
  • a daily round-up of the new posts on my blog.

The latter features more chocolate and less Nick Clegg than the former.

If one or both take your fancy, just sign up here.

One of the best MP videos I’ve seen

Another cracking video highlighting Lynne Featherstone’s work for her constituents, this time making Alexandra Palace train station accessible for everyone:

Can you support Lib Dem Newswire?

Lib Dem Newswire being read on a computerEach month, readership keeps on going up, which is fabulous – and comes with a small problem. Namely that the costs I have to pay out for the email service and related tools keep on edging up too from free, to not very much and now to quite noticeable. So I’ve set up an easy online donation form via the Patreon service which is widely used by artists and writers to support regular small donations.

You can sign up to donate $1 per month (or more if you wish; note that the form is in US dollars) here:

It’s fantastic seeing several thousands people enjoy reading my monthly newsletter, and it’d be brilliant if you can help cover the costs – thank you!

Who should you bet on for next party leader?

Tim FarronAs Mike Smithson often points out, the key to successful political betting is to identify those occasions where the odds of something happening are significantly different from the odds that bookies will offer you. Those are the value bets: where the event you are betting on has a greater chance of happening than the odds offered to you imply. You won’t win all your value betters but in the long run, value bets make you a profit.

So what’s the value bet for Liberal Democrat leader? Tim Farron is consistently the bookies’ favourite, at around evens. He’s certainly got a good chance of winning, but he’s not such a shoe-in as to make betting on him an obvious value bet.

The answer isn’t, either, the favourite of much media speculation Danny Alexander. Liberal Democrat members consistently rate him poorly compared to ministerial colleagues in the Lib Dem Voice member surveys, and other indicators – such as attendance and applause at his conference speeches – are good but not so good as to suggest those surveys are all wrong. The odds offered on him are not generous enough to make him a value bet, especially given the Ashcroft poll in his seat showing a tough fight.

Instead, for someone whose odds of winning are much better than those the bookies offer, look to Norman Lamb. Past talk of his leadership ambition has sometimes been overstated (his supposed expensive make-over involved actually rather cheap spectacles and a change in how he brushed his hair) but he’s got four major factors in his favour.

First, a large majority with the Tories as the main opposition, making his re-election prospects nearly as good as Tim Farron’s. Second, in fronting the party’s push to get mental health given the priority it deserves in the NHS, he is building up a strong record as an effective minister whilst at the same time doing so on an issue that plays very well with Lib Dem members and the wider public. Third, he has been effective at winning over party activists even when they have been initially hostile to his policy ideas – as happened a few years back with plans for the Royal Mail that conference rejected first time round. That willingness to engage and win over people in the party is important. Fourth, he will be able to line up an impressive list of endorsements from figures who are very popular with party members.

A Farron vs Lamb contest would certainly see Norman Lamb’s ‘Orange Book’ instincts played up and that could cost him the victory. But with odds as good as 8/1 available on him, he’s a stand out value bet.

Also doing well as a value bet is Alistair Carmichael at 20/1. He has ruled out running for leader, but he too has a big majority, a good record in government and significant popularity with figures who would be key endorsers in a contest. He also is more of a social liberal which would make it harder in some ways for him to compete with Tim Farron. But if he used his connections from being Chief Whip to line up a much larger list of MP and ex-MP backers than Tim Farron, that could well give many members pause for thought as to which of the two is the best social liberal to vote for. 20/1 looks good value too.

Others also fancy their chances – notably Ed Davey – but the gap between their chances of success and the odds currently being offered on them don’t make them value bets.

There is another weird category: those for whom the bookies offer non-astronomical odds despite the fact they won’t be an MP after the general election and in two cases aren’t even an MP now. Even at 33/1 it’s throwing money away placing a bet on David Howarth being the next party leader. Nor does 100/1 tempt me to bet on Chris Huhne being the next leader.

But one final thought: the incumbency benefits for Nick Clegg in the event of a hung Parliament are considerable. See Leaderless parties don’t make for good partners in hung Parliaments to find out why.

All the usual disclaimers about not blaming me if you place any bets apply and the odds were correct at the time of writing. The best odds available on different people are not all from the same bookmaker.

Sign up and keep up

Don’t miss out!

Are you reading a forwarded copy of Liberal Democrat Newswire? Or perhaps the web-based version? If so, then why not join thousands of others and sign up to receive direct to your email inbox future editions of what the Daily Telegraph calls a “must read” and of which Lynne Featherstone says “all Lib Dems should read this”?

Mike Hancock threatens to stand again

Mike Hancock MPKicked out by the Liberal Democrats, who have selected Gerald Vernon-Jackson to stand in Portsmouth South instead, the disgraced MP has been floating the idea of restanding in May.

There are, as Stephen Tall pointed out, almost 33,000 reasons why he might go through the even greater public humiliation and certain defeat that would follow putting his name on the ballot paper. MPs get a much better financial deal if they stand and lose than if they retire. In his case, it’ll be almost £33,000, of which the first £30,000 is tax free.

Unlocking Liberalism: a new book

Unlocking Liberalism: Life after the CoalitionA new collection of essays about the party’s future, Unlocking Liberalism – Life after the Coalition, has just been published, featuring contributions from David Steel, Graham Watson, Prateek Buch and The Equality Trust among others.

It argues the party needs to focus on its radical, challenging roots – rather than looking comfortable with taking up power in the established systems.

The book is available both from Amazon and direct from FastPrint.

And the winner is…

Free Radical: A Memoir by Vince CableMany thanks to everyone who took part in my Readers’ Survey 2015. I’m still digesting all the results and the many really useful comments made. My favourite so far is, “We don’t have anything like this in Canada”. Which is good, I think… You can still take part in the survey here.

The winner in the prize draw for a signed copy of Vince Cable’s excellent memoirs, Free Radical, is Edward Reach. Congratulations Edward!

If you’ve not yet read the memoirs and aren’t Edward, you can read my review here and buy a copy for yourself here.

Special reader offers

Graze healthy snacksGet your first box free if you sign up for tasty and healthy snacks through the post from Graze. You can cancel at any time, but if you stick with them you’ll then also get your fifth and tenth boxes free too. Just give the discount code MARKP2Q4E when signing up.

UK's #1 Cashback, Voucher Codes & Grocery Discount SiteSign up for Quidco and get cashback on your purchases at over 4,200 retailers. Rather than go direct to the retailers’ website you just go via Quidco and pocket discounts without having to make any further effort. It’s a fab deal.

(Note: I’m a happy customer of both. If you use the links it will help pay for the costs of sending out Liberal Democrat Newswire but more importantly, I hope you’ll be happy with them too!)

Please rate this edition

I really value the views of readers as it helps me decide what to include in future editions.

How much did you like this newsletter?

lowest 1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   highest
Sorry, voting is closed.

Thank you – and please forward

I hope you’re found this edition of Liberal Democrat Newswire interesting, informative, useful – or all three!

Like this newsletter? Then let your friends know about it too. Just point them at this sign-up page. You can catch up on previous editions by taking a look at the online archive.

Best wishes and thank you for reading,


MailChimp logoP.S. I use Mailchimp to power these newsletters and absolutely love it – it’s really powerful yet easy to use, and comes with a good range of free and low cost options. Plus their technical support team responds quickly and in plain English. If you’re after an email service yourself, you can sign up for a Mailchimp account here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments and data you submit with them will be handled in line with the privacy and moderation policies.