Media & PR

Daily Telegraph forced to publish correction for Toby Young’s claims

The Daily Telegraph has had to publish a correction after the press regulator IPSO ruled that it had published a piece from Toby Young containing false claims about coronavirus.

As The Guardian reports:

An article by Toby Young for the Daily Telegraph was “significantly misleading” when it said that catching a cold could protect people from coronavirus and claimed that London was approaching herd immunity, the press regulator has ruled.

In a decision published on Thursday, the Independent Press Standards Organisation (Ipso) complaints committee ordered the Telegraph to publish a correction over the column, which was appeared in July last year under the headline: “When we have herd immunity Boris will face a reckoning on this pointless and damaging lockdown.”

It’s worth noting that this was not just a case of a mistake slipping through. Rather, the Daily Telegraph tried to defend the article to the regulator. But the regulator found a string of errors and refusals to correct:

The publication … misrepresented the nature of immunity and implied that people previously exposed to some common colds might be automatically immune to suffering symptoms and passing on Covid-19 to others … The publication did not offer to correct this significantly misleading statement …

The statement that cross-reactive T-cells mean “that the population of London is probably approaching herd immunity” was significantly misleading. It was misleading both as to how herd immunity is reached and whether it existed in London … the newspaper did not offer to correct this significantly misleading statement.

As the correction states:

An article (11 July) about Covid 19 argued that people with cross-reactive T cells ‘ will have natural immunity’ having ‘already successfully fought off other coronaviruses ‘. This was incorrect as such people may still contract and transmit Covid. The article also wrongly proposed that ‘London is probably approaching herd immunity’ but cross-reactive T cells do not prevent infection spreading and therefore do not create herd immunity and there was no evidence to support such immunity was being established in London. This correction follows an upheld ruling by IPSO.

Sign up to get the latest news and analysis

"*" indicates required fields

What would you like to receive?*
If you submit this form, your data will be used in line with the privacy policy here to update you on the topic(s) selected. This may including using this data to contact you via a variety of digital channels.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

3 responses to “Daily Telegraph forced to publish correction for Toby Young’s claims”

  1. I think we need to point out how easy the Telegraph has made it for its readers to find the correction, unless the reader is specifically looking for it. I couldn’t spot it on their website (except by following your link) and I don’t know how prominent it is in the paper itself (because our local Morrison’s would object (quite rightly) if I picked up a copy and looked through every page in order to find it, before taking a photo of it and putting it back in their pile.

  2. Corrections MUST be put in prominent positions.
    Equally could it not be possible that his and there defence of the article could have led to an increase in infections at that time?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments and data you submit with them will be handled in line with the privacy and moderation policies.