14 Lib Dem rebels help defeat housing benefit cuts in the House of Lords

Fourteen Liberal Democrat peers, including the former party Chief Whip Archy Kirkwood and the former interim Chief Executive Ben Stoneham, joined a successful rebellion in the House of Lords today. The vote, on part of the Welfare Reform Bill, was over the proposal to cut housing benefit payments from people who have spare bedrooms in their property.

The peers voted to restrict these cuts to people who have two or more spare bedrooms, excluding the controversial category of people with one spare bedroom – which, under the rules as proposed, might in fact not have been that spare. Concerns had also been raised over the transitional arrangements for people who would be hit by the cuts if they did not move soon.

The government lost the vote 258-190.


The Lib Dem rebels were:

  • Eric Avebury
  • Brian Cotter
  • Archy Kirkwood (former Chief Whip in the Commons)
  • Veronica Linklater
  • Ken Macdonald
  • Sue Miller (former Liberal Democrat Home Affairs spokesperson)
  • Roger Roberts
  • Ros Scott (former Party President)
  • John Shipley
  • Trevor Smith
  • Matthew Taylor (former chair of the party’s Campaigns and Communications Committee)
  • Celia Thomas
  • Jenny Tonge
  • Geoff Tordoff (former Chief Whip in the Lords)
Ben Stoneham abstained.

Thank you to Mark Valladares for helping with getting the full list from Hansard.

10 responses to “14 Lib Dem rebels help defeat housing benefit cuts in the House of Lords”

    • 44 voted they other way, so 58 voted in total out of 91 taking the whip. But not voting does not (as I'm sure you know!) always mean a positive abstention due to other factors such as illness.

    • Mark Pack I get that; I was using clumsy shorthand (thought about correcting myself but didn't bother). The upshot is: 33.

  1. I'm pleased the the lib dems have defended people with an illness or mobility problem. Its taken me years to find a suitable 2 bedroomed house, and I am not moving either.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All comments and data you submit with them will be handled in line with the privacy and moderation policies.