How UKIP is damaging Labour, reprised
Back in May I pointed out how May’s local elections showed UKIP hitting Labour the most, contrary to the widespread conventional wisdom. Now new data from ComRes makes a similar point.
First, that local election evidence:
Look how the votes have changed this year compared to last (using the BBC’s national equivalent vote share projections, i.e. this is comparing like with like as it adjusts for the different range of seats up for election):
UPDATES:
- There’s a good follow up piece by John Rentoul over on the Independent website.
- I thought the text in brackets at the top of this post was pretty clear :), but judging by some of the reactions to this post along the lines of ‘OMG! That can’t possibly be true! You’re not comparing like with like!’, it’s worth emphasising the point again – these figures are about what has happened to the levels of support for parties in 2013 compared with 2012. The figures take into account the different range of wards up for election last year and this as they are national equivalent vote share calculations. This post on the LSE site has a good introduction to what those calculations are and what they mean.
Now for the new ComRes evidence:
There has been much debate about what effect the rise of UKIP is having and who it is taking votes from. Our polling shows that the party is taking much more support from past Conservative voters than past Labour voters (according to our latest online poll, UKIP took 19% of 2010 Tories, but just 7% of 2010 Labour voters).
However, the graph above shows that UKIP is affecting Labour’s vote share by pulling away potential new voters who previously sided with the Tories, and that once upon a time, in a two-party past, might have switched to them when frustrated with the governing party midterm.
This has a number of effects. The first is that while UKIP are performing well, it is likely to bring down the ceiling of Labour’s potential vote share, something that should worry the Opposition as it searches for a majority.
SeanAsh28 UKIP labourpress Labour dont see #UKIP coming – Labour votes collapsing up in North –
SeanAsh28 UKIP labourpress As UKIP London Chairman I have seen it at 1st hand -there is a real sense of betrayal among Labourt supporters
DavidCoburnUKip UKIP labourpress bexleynews 2014 is an open race: Anyone can win if they work hard enough! Au revoir à l’établissement!
stgeorgeiscross Good, hope labour get destroyed 2015.
DavidCoburnUKip its hardly surprising, labour are wandering around like headless chickens, no one knows what they are or stand for anymore
gavtheukip DavidCoburnUKip #lab vote collapsing is a sign that #ukip are winning the argument on immigration,wanting control is not racist
gavtheukip the millions of decent people who vote Labour know what it stands for. DavidCoburnUKip
oafaaftooth DavidCoburnUKip well UKIP are the only party willing to tackle the immigration problem, lib/lab/con just bury heads in sand
oafaaftooth DavidCoburnUKip a lot needs to be dealt with, but priority must be aimed at leaving the EU, as we have no powers whilst in it
DavidCoburnUKip it was only a matter of time, people can see right through them.
fatty_m yep and that’s the problem! #ExLabour
DavidCoburnUKip This is only the beginning! Euroelections will be a wipeout!!!!
ManosUK DavidCoburnUKip Bear this in mind when the blue-boys bleat about UKIP/Tory Alliance.
ManosUK I hope so, I really hope so!!#UKIP
ManosUK DavidCoburnUKip Says the EU migrant from Greece.Better get your bags packed if ukip get in manos.