A lesson from history in tackling terrorism: The Gunpowder Plot

Antonia Fraser - The Gunpowder Plot - book coverAntonia Fraser’s lively and authoritative history The Gunpowder Plot: Terror & Faith in 1605 not only provides an entertaining account of the events that have turned November 5th into an annual fireworks celebration but also throws a light on how to tackle terrorism.

For the early seventeenth century world which spawned Guy Fawkes, Robert Catesby and an attempt to blow up Parliament was one in which there were widespread fears of plots and violence, motivated by differing religious views that led some (but not all) to see the future as inevitably bringing a violent confrontation for religious supremacy. Fears of terrorist conspiracy by an extremist minority in a religion that nominally owned obedience to an overseas religious figure all sounds rather contemporary.

Fraser’s skill in mixing the stories of individuals with the story of social tensions brings out the frequent difficulty in deciding quite who or what behaviour is beyond the pale. There was then a spectrum, with at one end a small number of Catholic extremists plotting violent treason but then moving on to those who supported the plot, even if they did not directly participate, those who knew of the plot and let it be, those who knew of the plot and privately tried to stop it (but did not call in the authorities), those who did not know of the plot but only by virtue of turning a blind eye and finally, those who knew of the plot and, probably, did tip off the authorities. Picking precisely where on that spectrum to draw legal culpability, especially in a world of imperfect evidence and conflicting accounts, is not easy and the existence of that spectrum means that successfully tackling the extremists at one end often means appealing to – rather than antagonising – those further along the spectrum.

Aside from the strength of these modern parallels, the other aspect of the book which most surprised me was the role of women in keeping the Catholic religion going in England. The paucity of legal and property rights for women meant that they were, ironically, largely protected from the financial penalties levied on Catholics at the time. Therefore in many families, the wife remained a Catholic, bringing up children (at least until adulthood) as Catholics too but with the husband and other adult men in the family paying obedience to the demands of Protestantism.

At heart, however, is the well told story of the plotters, their attempts to blow up Parliament and the consequences for them and for many other Catholics. It is a good read, even without those other bonus perspectives.

Got a view on this review? Then please rate it on Amazon.

Buy Antonia Fraser’s The Gunpowder Plot: Terror & Faith here.

The Gunpowder Plot: Terror And Faith In 1605 by Antonia Fraser
A lesson from history in tackling terrorism
My rating (out of 5): 5.0
Mark Pack, 5 November 2018 |

One response to “A lesson from history in tackling terrorism: The Gunpowder Plot”

  1. Middle and upper class women of the period were often assertive and well-educated despite their subjected legal position. For example, Anne Hutchinson, the puritan wife of the Civil War Parliamentary commander and regicide John Hutchinson, had translated Catullus from the Latin (not an obviously puritanical thing to do) and tended wounded men of both armies. On both sides there were women who took control of fortified positions in the absence of their husbands. It’s believed to be from the Civil War period that the song of “sweet Polly Oliver” derives, in which a young woman masquerades as a man and becomes a soldier to be near her boyfriend.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments and data you submit with them will be handled in line with the privacy and moderation policies.